INVENTORY OF ABANDONED RAILROAD RIGHTS OF WAY REGION 6 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION i RAYMOND T. gcnumz, COMMIQSIONER
|
EVENTORY OF ABANDONED RAILROAD RIGHTS OF WAY _!z_Ew Yonx (STATE) BEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION. REAL PROPERTY DIVISION. REGION #6 COMPRISING THE couunns or`: ALLEGANY, CHEMUNG, SCHUYLER, STEUBEN, TIOGA & YATES 1974
GLOSSARY BALLAST - Crushed rook or gravel, used in railroad beds to provide ground stability for laying ties and tracks. BERM - A longitudinal mound of earth used to deflect water; a narrow ledge or shelf. CULVERT - Any structure not classified as a bridge which provides an opening under any roadway. o PRISM - Am applied to canals, the entire area encompassing the sides which are parallelograms. TRESTLE - A braced framework of timbers, piles or steelwork for carrying a railroad over a depression. ABBREVIATIONS R.R. - Railroad Rte. or Rt. - Route R.O.W. - Right of Way E/S - East Side W/S - West Side B & M - Boston and Maine D & H ` Delaware and Hudson ~ P. C. - Penn Central
G. E. - General Electric Company
C. R. - County Road T/O - Termination/Origin
TABLE OF CONTENTS | | | REGION #6 CASE STUDIES or ABANDONMENT LOCATION MAP CODE PAGE | Cattaraugus Co. Line to Wyoming Co. Line 6-2 Buffalo & Susquehanna .........|^~R....|^~R.. 6-7 Wellsville to Cattaraugus County Line 6-3 Pittsburg, Shaumut & Northern |^~R..|^~R.... 6-14 Wayland ~ Hornell - Ceres 6-4 New York & Pennsylvania ...................... 6-24 Canisteo v Pennsylvania State Line 6-5 Prattsburg Railway |^~R..|^~R..|^~R. 6-26 Kanona - Prattsburg 6-6 Wellsville, Addison &-Galeton Railway ..|^~R... 6-32 Addison to Pennsylvania State Line 6*.7 | 'Ot.O`.t..'.'......@@I.@l@@@@@I@ | - Wayland - Corning 6~8 Delaware-Lackawanna & Western .....|^~R....... 6e44 Corning - Pennsylvania State Line 6-9 Elmira Water, Light & Railroad Company ..|^~R. 6-49 Watkins Glenn - Horseheads 6-10 Penn Yan & Lake Shore Railway Company ........ 6-52 Penn Yan - Branchport | Rushville-Middlesex-Ontario County Line III
LOCATION MAP CODE PAGE 6-12 Elmira State Line Railroad Co, & Erie Railroad Co|^~R. , |^~R. 6-57 Elmira to Pennsylvania State Line 6-13 Elmira, Corning and Waverly Railroad Co|^~R. 6-59 South Corning - Elmira - Waverly 6-14 Lehigh Valley (Elmira-Cortland Branch) |^~R. 6-64 Horseheads - Candor - Tompkins Co. Line 6-15 Delaware, Lackawanna & Western (Ithaca Br.)|^~R. 6-71 Owego - Candor 6-16 (NOTE): D. L. & W., a/k/a Erie-Lackawanna Railroad (Research picked up on Region #4, Livonia-Wayland) 6-17 Corning Sodus Bay Railroad |^~R. 6-75 Savona - Wayne 6-18 Hornell Traction Railroad |^~R. 6-76 Hornell - Canisteo 6-19 Wellsville Bolivar Railroad |^~R. 6-77 Wellsville - Bolivar 6-20 Wellsville, Addison & Galeton Railroad . |^~R. 6-79 Wollmville - Penn. State Line
A. Approximate length 33 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 60' - 80'.
C. General Conditions
The entire right of way from the Town of Caledonia in Livingston County to Hinsdale in Cattaraugus County was purchased by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation from Penndel Company for $137,500.00, recorded in the Allegany County Clerk's Office in Liber 553, Page 954, dated January 28, 1964. The grantee has used very little of the right of way for transmission lines to date.
This investigation was completed from the Allegany- Cattaraugus County Line just west of Cuba to the Allegany-Wyoming County Line north of Rossburg.
ALLEGANY-CATTARAUGUS COUNTY LINE THROUGH CUBA TO SOUTHERN TIER EXPRESSWAY: CUBA-FRIENDSHIP
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 80 ft. c. Condition: Grass covered but clear. Some brush along the right of way. In Cuba, cinder covered and used as a street and then parking area for automobile sales and school. Crosses road near intersection of Rts. 408 and 305. It is then cinder or grass covered to Southern Tier Expressway. d. Structures: All bridges and some drainage structures removed. Some ties left along side of right of way but all other structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Pole barrier blocking right of way outside Cuba toward Southern Tier Expressway and sign owned by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling to level. g. General land use: Farming to residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and State Rts. 408 and 305.
SOUTHERN TIER EXPRESSWAY: CUBA-FRIENDSHIP TO JACKSON HILL ROAD
a. Length: 1 ½ miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Cinder covered with some grass. Brush grown up on each side of right of way. About 15' of usable and 30' of visible right of way. d. Structures: Three bridges out - all other structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Keep Out sign by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 305 and Erie-Lackawanna Railway.
JACKSON HILL ROAD TO SOUTH ROAD
a. Length: 1 ½ miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Cinder and grass covered. Easy to use. d. Structures: All bridge structures removed, some ties along side of right of way. e. Existing transportation facilities: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level, swampy. g. General land use: Farming and vacant waste; h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking (if bridges put back) i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 308 and Erie-Lackawanna Railway.
SOUTH ROAD TO ROUTE 305 CROSSING
a. Length: 9 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Cinder covered and can be driven upon between South Road and Tibbetts Hill Road. It is cinder and grass covered from Tibbetts Hill Road to Rt. 305 crossing, but broken in places where bridges removed. The old right of way passes under large bridge at Rt. 305. d. Structures: The concrete drainage structure between South and Hyder Flats Roads was left in right of way. The bridges (4) have been removed between Tibbetts Hill Road and Rt. 305 crossing. Some ties left in right of way that were probably used on a second track in this area. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level and swampy. g. General land use: Vacant waste. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking, only if bridges replaced. i. Existing transportation facilities: Parallel to Erie-Lackawanna Railway and near Rt. 308.
308 CROSSING TO GLEASON ROAD
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered past Rockville Lake where the road behind encroaches on to the right of way, but it is clear and easy to travel upon to Gleason Road. Tree and brush lined all the way. d. Structures: All bridges (4) removed. Some ties left along side of right of way. e. Indication of ownership: Signs that say property owned by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. Farmers install fences with Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. permission. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking in some places. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railway nearby. Lake Road and Rt. 305.
GLEASON HILL ROAD TO ORAMEL
a. Length: 2 ½ miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Cinder or grass covered built up right of way. Easy to follow. Some high trees and brush on either side of the right of way. d. Structures: All structures removed. However, some ties and tracks left in Belfast that are being used by local business. They are not on the general right of way. e. Indication of ownership: Keep Out signs, Rochester Gas and Electric, some farm fences. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 19.
ORAMEL TO CANEADEA (RT. 243)
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Cinder and grass covered to Caneadea. In Caneadea most of old right of way has been turned into garden or yard area. d. Structures: All structures including bridges have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: The use of right of way as yards and gardens. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming, - residential in Oramel and Caneadea. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rte. 19.
CANEADEA (RTE. 243) TO HOUGHTON
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft; c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered - tree and brush lined - clear. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Signs by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming and residential in the villages. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rte. 19.
HOUGHTON TO FILLMORE
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered. d. Structures: All removed. e. Indication of ownership: High voltage wire line owned by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Residential and farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 19.
FILLMORE TO WYOMING COUNTY LINE
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. a. Condition: Clear grass and cinder covered right of way, brush lined. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: High voltage wire lines and signs owned by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Farming or residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 19 and West Road.
The right of way is generally clear and usable, except where bridges have been removed, over its entire length in Allegany County. Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation has utilized very little of the right of way to date. It can easily be used for transportation or recreational purposes.
A. Approximate length 38 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 60 ft.
C. General Conditions
The Buffalo and Wellsville Railway was abandoned November 17, 1916. It was part of the Buffalo and Susquehanna Railway Corporation. The Buffalo and Susquehanna Railway Corporation sold the line to the Susquehanna Finance Corporation. This transaction was filed in the Allegany County Clerk's Office on December 13, 1915 in Liber 229, Page 279.
WELLSVILLE TO SCIO (KNIGHT CREEK ROAD)
a. Length: 5 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The old ROW in Wellsville has disappeared except for a short distance from the flood project to Rt. 17 where it is clear and grass covered. It is interrupted by the old airport. Grass or cinder covered from the old airport to Scio. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Tillable fields and pastures. power and telephone lines on ROW. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: State Rts. 17 and 19.
SCIO TO BELMONT
a. Length: 5 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The old ROW is grass or cinder covered between these two villages. It is broken in places and very difficult to find. In some places it is very heavily brush lined. In other places it disappears. Most of it has returned to residential use in Belmont and is hard to follow. d. Structures: All structures removed except cement drainage structures. e. Indication of ownership: Farm fields and pasture fences. f. Nature of terrain: Level low land. g. General land use: Farming except in Belmont where it is residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Black River Road.
BELMONT TO BELVIDERE
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered ROW that is brush and tree lined. The section near Belvidere has disappeared. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Pole lines owned by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp., posted signs by windy Hill Farms, Pennsylvania Hill, Hornell (Friendship Hill Road), Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. substation on Cemetery Hill Road in Belmont. f. Nature of terrain: Hilly. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt, 19.
BELVIDERE TO TRANSIT BRIDGE
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass covered and easy to follow. Broken only by the Southern Tier Expressway: Belmont- Almond: Part l. It is easy to follow even through the woods. d. Structures: All structures except concrete drainage structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Pole line by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. and farm fences. f. Nature of terrain: Side hill. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Parallel to Rt. 19.
TRANSIT BRIDGE TO BELFAST (GLEASON HILL ROAD)
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass and light brush covered along side hill and parallel to Rt. 19. It is brush or tree lined almost the entire length. In a few places it was returned to tillable farm land. Occasionally some has been used to widen Rt. 19. d. Structures: All bridges have been removed including those across the Black Creek Gorge (cement center foundation still standing). e. Indication of ownership: Farm fences and gates. f. Nature of terrain: Side hill to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Parallel to Rt. 19.
BELFAST TO CANEADEA (RUSSELL HILL ROAD)
a. Length: 4 ½ miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: It is grass and brush covered from Gleason Hill Road through Belfast to Hughes Road. It has been returned to tillable land in places and disappears in others. It is high grass and small brush covered from Hughes Road to Russell Hill Road. It has some trees growing in the ROW where it goes through the woods. d. Structures: All structures except drainage have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Fences, lawn owned by W. Raslawsky, and posted sign, Chaba, Caneadea. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling to hilly. g. General land use: Farming or recreational h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Gleason Hill Road, Hughes Road, Crawford Creek Road, McNamara Hill Road and Russell Hill Road.
CANEADEA TO RUSHFORD
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The road is used as a lumber road for about ½ mile from Russell Hill Road. It then becomes grass and brush covered with some small trees in the ROW until you reach Street Road at the Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. picnic area. The structure is gone across Caneadea Creek at the head of Rushford Lake and the old ROW is in a deep trench until just before reaching Lake Road. Lake Road covers the old ROW until it reaches Sand Hill Road. d. Structures: All structures removed except some drainage structures. Station in Rushford still standing. e. Indication of ownership: Rochester Gas and Electric Corp. signs, fences and pastures. f. Nature of terrain: Hilly. g. General land use: Farming and recreational, some residential near Rushford Lake. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Lake Road, Rt. 243.
RUSHFORD TO TUCKER ROAD
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Grass covered ROW used as pasture to Curren Road where a portion of the old ROW is under Curren Road. It is still grass covered and used as pasture to Tucker Road. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Fences. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Curren Road and Tucker Hill Road.
TUCKER ROAD TO COUNTY ROUTE 23
a. Length: 1 mile. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The ROW becomes brush covered but soon returns to grass covered. It is tree and brush lined on both sides, Returned to farming after crossing Wesley Road until it enters woods where it is easy to observe, to County Route 23. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Tucker and Wesley Roads.
COUNTY Room 23 TO BALLARD ROAD
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: It is used as a farm road and then brush and grass covered to Weaver Road. It crosses Weaver Road where it is grass covered and built up until it reaches Ballard Road. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Pasture fences. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: County Route 23, Weaver Road, Ballard Road.
BALLARD ROAD TO CATTARAUGUS COUNTY LINE
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: It is grass covered and brush lined from Ballard Road to Swift Road to the County Line. In places the ROW is covered with light brush. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Hilly. g. General land use: Recreational. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Ballard Road and Swift Road.
The ROW is generally grass covered and tree lined from Wellsville to the Cattaraugus County Line. It is easy to follow just about the entire length.
A. Approximate length 86 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 60 ft.
C. General Conditions
The Pittsburgh, Shaumut & Northern Railroad operated the last train over its tracks on April 1, 1947. The entire railroad was purchased by Harry W. Findley for $1,505,000 on March 4, 1947 according to a historian, Paul Pietrak. The records in the Allegany County Clerk's Office show that the railroad was bought by the SPN Realty Holding Company for Mr. Findley. These transactions are filed under Liber 399, Page 400 dated March 31, 1947 and Liber 404, Page 405 dated July 30, 1947 in the Allegany County Clerk's Office.
There are approximately 90 miles of abandoned Shaumut & Northern Railroad right of way in New York State with most of it located in Allegany and Steuben Counties. The railroad extended from Wayland to Olean with a spur line to Hornell. The railroad purchased a 60' ROW for this line but only about 20' is evident today.
The purchaser gathered up and sold all rails, ties, signal facilities, bridges, and culverts on the entire length of the road.
The following is a report of the conditions of the roadbed today.
WAYLAND TO STONY BROOK GLEN
a. Length: 6 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. (20' to 30' are evident in the field). c. Condition: The roadbed is clear and either cinder covered or grass covered from Wayland to Stony Brook Glen except where it is broken by yards and a pasture in Perkinsville and the Genesee Expressway. It has also been returned to farming near the old Rogersville Station. d. Structures: All structures were removed including the old trestle over Stony Brook Glen. e. Indication of ownership: The presence of fences and tillable fields are signs of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Gently rolling to side hill to level land. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: County highways.
STONY BROOK GLEN TO MORAINE (HORNELL JUNCTION)
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. (20' to 30' evident). c. Condition: The old ROW passes through woods and open fields between these two points. Some of the old ROW has been returned to farming or used as pasture. It is either grass, light brush or cinder covered. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Some fences, pastures, tillable fields and a barn on the ROW near Rt. 36 are signs of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Hilly or level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 36.
HORNELL TO MORAINE (HORNELL JUNCTION)
a. Length: 10 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. (15' can be used). c. Condition: The old ROW is clear and cinder covered from Hornell to the Canisteo River except where the Southern Tier Expressway: Almond-Hornell crosses the old ROW. The ROW is grass and brush covered from the Canisteo River to Arkport, This section has a 3 ft. drainage ditch from Crowley Dairies going down the center. The ROW is cinder covered or grass covered all the way to Moraine. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: The presence of buildings in Arkport, the ditch, and a fence are signs private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming or residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 70 and Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
MORAINE TO CANASERAGA
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. width - where evident only about 20 ft. c. Condition: Most of this section has been returned to farming except where it goes through woods. In the woods it is completely overgrown with brush. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Tillable farm use. f. Nature of terrain: Generally level to rolling. g. General land use: harming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways and Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
CANASERAGA
a. Length: ½ mile. b. Widths 60 ft. width. c. Condition: The roadbed has about disappeared in the village. d. Structures: The old railroad station is still standing. All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: The C. Pfeil Lumber Company and Shay Construction Company are built upon the ROW, Paul Pettey's Feed Mill is an encroachment upon the old ROW. It is also used as a storage area and possible encroachment by Canaseraga Agway and by Charles Oliver and Son. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Commercial. b. Recreational possibilities: None. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways and Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
CANASERAGA TO SWAINS
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The ROW is still evident and either cinder covered or grass and light brush covered where it has not been returned to farming. In several places the old ROW has been returned to tillable and pasture land. d. Structures: All structures have been removed except where the Canaseraga Creek goes under the old horseshoe trestle. The bridge over the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad is missing. e. Indication of ownership: Fences and use as tillable fields are signs of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Road for biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways and Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
SWAINS TO BIRDSALL
a. Length: 8 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The ROW is clear and grass covered until it enters the woods where it becomes brush and small tree covered. Upon leaving the woods it travels through a level swampy area to Birdsall. Along side hills are deep outs where the drainage pipes were removed. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Some fences are signs of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: From level to hill and gently rolling to level low swampy. g. General land use: Farming or recreational. h. Recreational possibilities: Road for hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways.
BIRDSALL TO ANGELICA
a. Length: 10 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Clear and grass covered (tree lined) along the side of the hill until it drops into the valley and continues until it crosses Rt. 408. It then disappears until it recrosses Rt. 408 into a tillable field. It is a grass covered ROW with trees on each side until it recrosses Rt. 408 again and continues until it disappears where it crosses Black Creek. The ROW is either grass covered or cinder covered from Black Creek to Railroad Avenue in Angelica. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. Some concrete pillars from the old bridge over Black Creek near Angelica are still standing. e. Indication of ownership: Presence of fences and return of parts of the old ROW to tillable and pasture land. f. Nature of terrain: The ROW passes along side hill, woods and level land. g. General land use: Woods or farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Road hiking trails. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways (Rt. 408).
VILLAGE OF ANGELICA
a. Length: ½ mile. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The roadbed is used as Railroad Avenue - blacktop. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Used as village street. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Biking and hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highway.
ANGELICA TO BELVIDERE
a. Length: 5 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: Railroad Avenue becomes a cinder path for about .7 mile until it is stopped by a ditch. The ROW continues to be grass covered or cinder covered to the construction of the Southern Tier Expressway: Belmont-Almond: Part 1. It is easily traveled except for a couple of fences. The rest of the ROW to Belvidere is used as part of the Southern Tier Expressway. There are ditches where drainage ditches were removed. d. Structures: All structures including drainage pipes were removed. e. Indication of ownership: Fences only sign of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Hilly and rolling land. g. General land use: Woods. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Highways.
BELVIDERE TO FRIENDSHIP
a. Length: 9 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The ROW is grass and brush covered from Belvidere to Hess Road. From Hess Road almost to Pine Road is used for the Southern Tier Expressway: Friendship-Belmont. From Pine Road to Grove Road it is partially covered by a dump and then grass covered. d. Structures: All structures were removed. e. Indication of ownership: Dump area. f. Nature of terrain: Level land. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt, 408.
FRIENDSHIP
a. Length: 1 mile. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: From Grove Road the ROW becomes grass covered and hard to follow but it continues through Friendship. It passes the old station and then through a lawn and becomes a private road. It becomes a storage area for Allegany County Highways and New York State Department of Transportation but it is still clear enough to use. d. Structures: All structures removed - however, the old rails are still in the roadway of Elmwood Avenue. e. Indication of ownership: Storage area. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling land. g. General land use: Residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 408.
FRIENDSHIP TO RICHBURG
a. Length: 11 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: It is clear and grass covered to Nile. Some area is tree lined - can use about 20' of width. From Nile to Richburg the ROW travels along the side of the hills through woods. It is usually grass covered but in places it has been used and is cinder covered. It is only broken where the drainage pipes were removed or-where it crosses roads. However, it can just about all be traveled. It is very easy to follow until Inavale Road near Richburg. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: A few fences. f. Nature of terrain: Hillside land. g. General land use: Vacant land - recreational. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 34.
RICHBURG AND BOLIVAR
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The old ROW can be seen as it passes through these two villages. It is usually grass covered and has some brush on the ROW. It does disappear in some areas; but it is easy to follow. Also easy to follow through Bolivar. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Used as storage or back lawns - one house built on ROW between the two cities. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Recreational. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 17.
RICHBURG TO CERES
a. Length: 9 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The old ROW is grass or cinder covered and can be traveled just about the entire length. It is broken by a golf course and a pasture near Obi Road. Where it crosses Rt. 17 it is used as a private road with some houses on the road. 4 d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Golf course, private road sign and pasture fence; Rochester Gas and Electric poles down part of ROW. f. Nature of terrain: Gently rolling to level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Near Rt. 17.
CERES
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 60 ft. c. Condition: The ROW is grass covered and disappears near the old station. It has a garage and possibly a trailer located on the old ROW, It is found again outside Ceres and is grass covered and continues toward Olean. d. Structures: All structures removed. Old railroad station is used as a repair garage. e. Indication of ownership: The trailer, garage, auto repair shop, and farm fences are signs of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 17.
A. Approximate length 28 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 66'.
C. General Conditions The New York and Pennsylvania Railroad Company was originally called the Rochester, Hornellsville, and Pine Creek Railroad. The railroad was dissolved on April 10, 1937. The railroad connected Canisteo with points in Pennsylvania traveling through Greenwood, Rexville and Whitesville. The railroad property in the Towns of Canisteo, Greenwood and West Union in Steuben County and the Towns of Independence and Willing in Allegany County were sold.
The railroad property was sold by Robert L. Cobb as permanent receiver for the New York and Pennsylvania Railroad. The following are real estate transfers of the property:
George J. Burd | 465 | 455 |
J. Earl Knapp | 470 | 145 |
Roy W. Rogers | 464 | 504 |
Godfrey L. Cabot, Inc. | 464 | 513 |
Archie B. Moore & wf. | 470 | 190 |
Jesse E. Armstrong & wf, | 470 | 389 |
Harold R. Eason | 470 | 436 |
Harold White & wf. | 470 | 606 |
CANISTEO TO PENNSYLVANIA LINE
a. Length: 28 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: The old right of way roadbed has just about disappeared on the entire length. It can be seen only in a few places where a path of brush is seen through the woods or a built up section through a pasture. Where it is evident, it can be seen only for short distances. It was returned to farming where it crossed fields. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Farm fences and tillable fields. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling to level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Some hiking possible. i. Existing transportation facilities: State Rt. 408.
A. Approximate length 12 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 50'.
C. General Conditions The Prattsburg Railway Corporation suspended operation for good in October of 1959. A Certificate was filed in the Steuben County Clerk's Office on July 6, 1961 in Liber 790, Page 285 announcing the auction sale of the entire railway corporation. This auction was held on June 10, 1961.
The following are the transfers of record of the railway property as the result of the auction. The property was sold by Warren C. Mcconnell, J. Harold McConne11, and
G. Merlin Drumm as Trustees for the bond holders of the Prattsburg Railway Corporation.
Rochester Iron & Metal | 791 | 355 |
Tadder Lumber Co., Inc. | 794 | 537 |
Stanley H. Maobougal & wf. | 796 | 679 |
J. Richard Seligman | 796 | 935 |
Harry Cw Decker & wf. | 797 | 172 |
Wm. Musnicki & wf. | 797 | 650 |
Audra Flint | 798 | 702 |
J. B. Flint & wf. | 798 | 704 |
Walter J. Skimina & wf. | 801 | 672 |
Lynn Z. Silsbee & wf. | 803 | 254 |
Michael Gerych & wf. | 807 | 956 |
Joseph T. Baily | 811 | 152 |
Graves & Cleland, Inc. | 811 | 724 |
The Prattsburg Railway Corporation was approximately 12 miles long and 50 ft. wide. The right of way was located between Kanona and Prattsburg. The old stations are still standing but under private ownership in Kanona, Wheeler, and Prattsburg. However, the old station in Kanona has been moved to a different location. Many of the old railroad buildings in Prattsburg are now owned by S. M. MacDougal Potatoes.
KANONA TO ROUTE 53 CROSSING
a. Length: 2 miles (approximately). b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: The old ROW is grass covered and brush lined. There is about 15' that could be used. It is now broken by the Southern Tier Expressway: Avoca-Bath Section and some grading done by Kanona Equipment, Inc. located on Hemlock Road. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Farm fences and use as storage area by Kanona Equipment. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53 only.
ROUTE 53 CROSSING TO LARVE ROAD
a. Length: 1 l/2 miles. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: The ROW is grass covered and easy to travel upon. It is tree and brush lined, It begins on level land until it is cut into the side of a hill and then back to level land again. In places it is a well traveled path. d. Structures: The bridge across the stream has been removed although the old concrete abutments remain. All the concrete and rock drainage structures remain. Some ties are left in the old roadbed in places but they are level with the ROW. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level or side hill - some swamp. g. General land use: Recreational - vacant land. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53.
LARVE ROAD TO WHEELER
at Length: 1 ½ miles. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: The old ROW is grass and brush covered but still tree lined, This section of ROW is poor for about half the distance between these two points, then it becomes just grass covered and easy to follow. d. Structures: The stone and cement drainage structures are still in place. Some old railroad ties are found pushed to the side of the ROW. The old station and two other buildings are still standing. e. Indication of ownership: Keep Out sign on Wheeler end of this section; house trailer on ROW. f. Nature of terrain: Level - swampy. g. General land use: Vacant or part time farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53.
WHEELER TO ROUTE 13
a. Length: ½ mile. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: High grass covered and brush and tree lined. Easy to follow. d. Structures: None. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Vacant (recreational) - swamp. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt, 53.
ROUTE 13 TO DINEHARTS CROSSING ROAD
a. Length: ½ mile. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: Grass covered, built up ROW. Very few trees along ROW. Very little brush. Some used as barn drive. Used as pasture and all fenced. d. Structures: Bridge out. e. Indication of ownership: Pasture fence and use as farm road. f. Nature of terrain: Level - swampy. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53.
DINEHARTS CROSSING ROAD TO BEANS STATION ROAD
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 49 l/2 ft. c. Condition: Starts out high grass covered and about 30' wide with trees and brush along the edge. Easy to travel upon. d. Structures: All bridges removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling - swampy in parts. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53.
BEANS CROSSING TO WALDO ROAD
a. Length: 1 mile. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: Clear and grass covered - tree lined easy to follow. d. Structures: Two bridges removed but concrete base still in creek banks. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level - swamp. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53,p
WALDO ROAD TO PRATTSBURG
a. Length: 1 ½ miles. b. Width: 49 ½ ft. c. Condition: Starts out grass covered (knee high) and tree lined. Can be traveled upon. Some has been returned to farming near Flynn Road. The ROW continues as grass covered and tree lined to Prattsburg. d. Structures: Old station still standing; bridges removed. e. Indication of ownership: Most buildings in old yard seem to be owned by S, M. McDougall Potatoes. The old station is owned by Graves & Cleland, Inc. f. Nature of terrain: Rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 53
The general condition of the ROW is good. It is easy to follow and could be traveled by bicycle or automobile the entire 10 miles if it wasn't for the bridges being out and a few fences crossing the right of way.
A. Approximate length 9 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 66'.
C. General Conditions The Wellsville, Addison and Galeton Railway was abandoned as the Unadilla Valley Railroad Company and sold for taxes on October 31, 1961. The Unadilla Valley Railroad ROW located in the Town of Tuscarora is approximately 8 miles in length and 3 rods wide starting north at the Addison Town Line and runs south terminating at the Pennsylvania State Line near Elkland, Pennsylvania.
The acquisition of the property by Steuben County was filed in Liber 823, Page 207 and was known as Tax Property 3602.
The following are the transfers of record of the abandoned railroad property:
Unadilla Valley Railway Company to Town of Tuscarora in Liber 828, Page 24, recorded on April 22, 1965.
County of Steuben to Norman Fogalman in Liber 828, Page 949, recorded on May 25, 1963.
Steuben County to Robert A. Bloomquist and Anthony Makitra in Liber 829, Page 145, recorded on May 10, 1965.
ADDISON TO PENNSYLVANIA STATE LINE
a. Length: 9 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: The right of way disappeared in Addison except where it connected with the Erie. It is a grass or cinder covered right of way from Addison to Freeman. It runs along parallel with the Old Addison Back Road, and is encroached upon near Addison by the old right of way. It is grass covered from Freeman to where it crosses County Route 112. The old right of way is built up cinder-covered berm from the Rt. 112 crossing to the Pennsylvania State Line. d. Structures: The ties were left in the right of way particularly from Freeman to the Pennsylvania State Line. The bridges have been removed except for 2 wooden trestles between Freeman and the Rt. 112 crossing. The drainage structures have been left in the right of way. All railroad buildings and tracks were removed. e. Indication of ownership: A house trailer on the right of way in Freeman is the only sign of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: The right of way is on level ground in the Addison area but it soon goes along the side of the hills to the Rt. 112 crossing where it is in a swampy valley to the Pennsylvania State Line. g. General land use: The right of way goes through either woods or farm area. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: County Routes 85, 86 and 112, Old Addison Back Road.
A. Approximate length 46 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 66' - 200'.
C. General Conditions The Erie Railroad abandoned its line from Wayland to Corning a distance of approximately 46 miles in 1951. It was a single track line that went to Rochester. The right of way is parallel and adjacent to the D. L. & W. Railroad in many places therefore it is possible that this right of way is really not abandoned, over the entire length between Wayland and Corning.
The following are real estate transfers of record of Erie Railroad property between Wayland and Corning:
ERIE RAILROAD COMPANY TO:
Jack B. Bishop | 637 | 214 |
Ingersoll Rand Co. | 655 | 21 |
Carl B. Anderson | 661 | 290 |
Village of Bath | 664 | 161 |
LeRoy Dyal Co., Inc. | 622 | 110 |
Donald N. Macbougal | 684 | 558 |
Ingersoll Rand Co. | 692 | 33 |
Corning Fibre Box Corp. | 693 | 133 |
George D. MacBeth | 693 | 346 |
Charles H. Cappon | 711 | 453 |
Marvin J. Ward | 714 | 251 |
City of Corning | 724 | 590 |
Gary Sprague | 729 | 326 |
John Damrow | 733 | 285 |
Leon J. Klien | 733 | 489 |
First Baptist Church of Avoca | 735 | 596 |
Corning Glass Works | 738 | 93 |
N.Y.S. Electric & Gas Corp. | 748 | 79 |
City of Corning | 750 | 421 |
D. L. & W. Railroad | 759 | 547 |
Coopers Plains Methodist Church | 772 | 350 |
Mary A. Littler | 773 | 153 |
Richard P. Lightfoot | 773 | 188 |
Harry A. Erwin | 773 | 385 |
Harry A. Erwin | 773 | 381 |
Ann Allen | 778 | 466 |
Erie Land and Improvement Company to Martha N. Lucas - dated 10-l9-5l - Liber 625, Page 177 - Corning Town.
Erie Land and Improvement Company to Richard P. Lightfoot - Liber 73, Page 192 - dated 4-l-60 - Corning Town.
LIVINGSTON - STEUBEN COUNTY LINE TO SAWDUST ROAD
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered from County Line to Wayland. In Wayland grass covered and clear except for wood storage on right of way by Woodcraftery, Inc. Grass covered from Wayland to Sawdust Road. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: No thoroughfare sign in Wayland. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Commercial or residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Stares Routes 21 & 15; County Routes 63 & 245.
SAWDUST ROAD TO PARKS ROAD
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Dirt and cinder covered entire length between 2 roads, no bridges in this section. d. Structures: Cement markers JC 333 & 334, cement drainage Structures. Some ties along the right of way. e. Indication of ownership: None - in places parallel and adjacent to E. & L. Railroad and within the fenced-in right of way. Some of this section may not really be abandoned. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking (drove auto between two roads). i. Existing transportation facilities: E. & L, Railroad, Sawdust and Parks Roads.
PARKS ROAD TO ATLANTA (COUNTY ROUTE 39 CROSSING)
a. Length: 1 mile. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Cinder and grass covered to Atlanta. In Atlanta some of old right of way turned into park and parking area. No bridges this section. d. Structures: All drainage structures left in right of way. All others removed. e. Indication of ownership: None except part of this section parallel and adjacent to E. & L. Railroad within their right of way fences. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities; Parks Road, County Route 39, E. & L. Railroad.
ATLANTA TO ATLANTA BACK ROAD (COHOCTON)
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: High grass over right of way leaving Atlanta. Cinder covered road outside Atlanta until it reaches stream where bridge out. Continues clear and grass covered on other side until it crosses Atlanta Back Road. d. Structures: Bridges and other structures removed. Concrete drainage structures still in right of way. e. Indication of ownership: Parallel to E. & L. Railroad and within the right of way fences. f. Nature of terrain: Level - swampy. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: E. & L. Railroad, County Routes 36 & 39.
COHOCTON
a. Length: l mile. b. Width: 200 ft. c. Condition: From Atlanta Back Road to Cohocton it is high grass covered and not used. In Cohocton there is one spur line on old Erie Railroad right of way. Therefore, it is not an abandoned right of way in Cohocton. d. Structures: None in abandoned section. Tracks, ties, railroad crossing signs in Cohocton. e. Indication of ownership: Use of old railroad Station by A, H. Wilcox & Son. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Commercial. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: E. & L. Railroad, Route 15 and 371.
COHOCTON TO WALLACE
a. Length: 4 ½ miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: The ROW is high grass covered from Cohocton to stream crossing. It is then cinder covered from stream across Jones Road to Flint Road. The old right of way is grass covered and brush lined from Flint Road to Wentworth Road. It is grass and cinder covered from Wentworth Road to Wallace except where it is returned to farming in a few places. d. Structures: All removed except drainage structure, concrete markers and slow sign near stream crossing. e. Indication of ownership: Posted by Orrin Cragg, R. D. #1, Cohocton. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and some biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: E. & L. Railroad and Rt. 15.
WALLACE TO AVOCA
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered through Wallace to stream crossing (no bridge). It is very heavily grass covered from the stream crossing to Cross Road. The section from Cross Road to Avoca is clear and cinder covered and easy to follow. d. Structures: All except drainage structures removed. Some ties in right of way in Wallace. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and State Route 15.
AVOCA TO KANONA
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: The old right of way is cinder or grass covered between these two places except an approximately l/2 mile section used for Southern Tier Expressway: Avoca-Bath, Map No. 16, Parcel No. 39. Near Kanona right of way becomes yard or farm fields. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: State Rt. 15.
KANONA TO BATH
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. outside and approximately 150 ft. in Kanona. c. Condition: Through Kanona it is grass and cinder covered. It continues cinder and grass covered until it reaches Rt. 15 crossing where it is now interrupted by Southern Tier Expressway: Avoca-Bath, Map No. 62. It continues cinder covered until it becomes used again as operating right of way near Belfast Street by the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad. d. Structures: All removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: State Rt. 15.
BATH TO COUNTY ROUTE 11
a. Length: 1 ½ miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: In Bath to the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad because of the Southern Tier Expressway had to move its right of way from the old D. L. & W. right of way to the abandoned Erie, Then just outside Bath the railroad was returned to the original D. L. & W. right of way. Most of the old Erie right of way is under Southern Tier Expressway: Bath-Campbell, Pt. 1. The State of New York acquired abandoned right of way from the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad under Southern Tier Expressway: Bath-Campbell, Pt. 1, Maps 175 and 220. d. Structures: Not available. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Commercial. . h. Recreational possibilities: None. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and State Route 15.
COUNTY ROUTE 11 TO CAMPBELL
a. Length: 8 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Grass or cinder covered until the Southern Tier Expressway: Bath-Campbell, Pt, 2 crosses the old right of way. The Expressway covers most of this right of way through Savona. The right of way is built up cinder and grass covered from Savona to near Campbell where it again becomes part of the Southern Tier Expressway: Bath-Campbell, Pt. 2. The Southern Tier Expressway: Bath-Campbell, Pt. 2, Maps 2, 82, 89, 126, 134, 142, 144, 145, 146 and 175 acquired abandoned railroad right of way for highway purposes. d. Structures: Only drainage structures remain. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g, General land use: Farming and some residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Routes 15 & 415, Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
CAMPBELL TO COOPERS PLAINS
a. Length: 4 ½ miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: It is used as a spur from Campbell to Campbell Dairy. Just past Campbell Dairy it is crossed by Southern Tier Expressway: Campbell-Painted Post where it is grass and cinder covered until the Southern Tier Expressway: Campbell-Painted Post again crosses the right of way. It is cinder and grass covered from there and used as farm roads until it is again crossed by Southern Tier Expressway just outside Coopers Plains. It is again evident in Coopers Plains where it is first yard and then a street in Coopers Plains. d. Structures: All structures removed except one bridge used as a farm drive. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Some hiking where access available. i. Existing transportation facilities: Southern Tier Expressway: Campbell-Painted Post and Erie- Lackawanna Railroad.
COOPERS PLAINS TO SUNSET AVENUE (PAINTED POST)
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Just outside Coopers Plains used as storage area for lumber mill. It is grass covered and soon becomes used as siding for Blair Supply Corp. It is cinder covered from Blair Supply Corp. to Sunset Avenue. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level; g. General land use: Farming. h, Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad, Southern Tier Expressway: Campbell- Painted Post.
PAINTED POST CORNING
a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: 66 ft. c. Condition: Grass and cinder covered from Sunset Avenue until it goes under the Southern Tier Expressway: Campbell-Painted Post. The right of way is clear and cinder covered under Rt. 415 until it comes to Steuben Street where this road was reconstructed across the right of way. It is again grass and cinder covered from Steuben Street until it leaves the City of Corning. Much of this right of way is parallel to the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad. d. Structures: Bridges are still standing over Charles Street, Reynolds Street, Dodge Street, and Baker Street. Drainage structures have been left in right of way. The old railroad station is on Steuben Street. e. Indication of ownership: Keep-Out signs by City of Corning. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Residential or commercial. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Many streets and highways and Erie-Lackawanna Railroad. Note: Some of this right of way in Corning is parallel and adjacent to the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and a part of its right of way. Therefore, it may not be considered abandoned.
A. Approximate length 28 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 80'.
C. General Conditions The State of New York appropriated approximately 38 miles of the abandoned Delaware-Lackawanna and Western Railroad between Corning and Binghamton. An Agreement of Adjustment was made on October 30, 1962 between the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad Company and the People of the State of New York to convey this right of way. This was appropriated under the following projects: S. H. 420, Vestal, Maps 294, 298 S. H. 5215, Owego-Binghamton, Maps 40 & 41, Broome County Southern Tier Expressway: Section 30 of the Highway Law Broome, Tioga, Chemung and Steuben Counties Maps 1-131 The appropriation in Region 6 is in 3 sections as follows: Section I: The Broome-Tioga Line to Mile Post Point 235 + 12, Station 12414.4 Section II: Mile Post 254.26, Station 13425.0 to Mile Post 261.65, Station 13815.0 Section III: Mile Post 275 + 51, Station 14546.7 to Mile Post 278 + 52, Station 14711.1
CORNING TO EAST CORNING
a. Length: 3 miles. b. Width: 80'. c. Condition: This is a clear and grass or cinder covered right of way which is parallel and adjacent to the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad right of way. d. Structures: All structures have been removed. There was only one small bridge in this section and it was removed. e. Indication of ownership: Owned by the State of New York. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Residential or vacant waste. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 17 and the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad.
EAST CORNING TO BIG FLATS (OLCOTT ROAD)
a. Length: 8 miles. b. Width: 80 ft. c. Condition: Cinder or grass covered between these two points. It is easy to travel upon with car. d. Structures: Three bridges are out over dirt roads. All structures removed except drainage structures. e. Indication of ownership: Owned by the State of New York. f. Nature of terrain: Level. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and Rt. 17. Note: The right of way in Big Flats is used as spur line to Agway and others. Must still belong to the railroad.
BIG FLATS TO HORSEHEADS
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 80 ft. c. Condition: Grass covered and brush lined right of way that is easy to follow as it is in a deep cut. It continues until it is used for highway near A. & P. Plant. I d. Structures: All structures except highway bridges over old right of way have been removed. Three large bridges cross old right of way in this area. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad, Rt. l7 and Rt. 427.
HORSEHEADS AND ELMIRA
The right of way is still being used as a spur line by the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad in these two cities.
ELMIRA TO LOWMAN
a. Length: 7 miles. b. Width: 80 ft. c. Condition: It is grass or cinder covered. It has been used as road along the river. d. Structures: All structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Rural residential or farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or biking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Rt. 17.
LOWMAN TO PENNSYLVANIA LINE
a. Length: 6 miles. b. Width: 80 ft. c. Condition: It is grass and cinder covered between these two points. d. Structures: Two large bridges over the river have been removed. All other structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: Level to rolling. g. General land use: Farming. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and Rt. 17. Portions of this right of way were used in the construction of the Southern Tier Expressway.
A. Approximate length 17.5 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 15'.
C. General Conditions The Elmira Water, Light and Railroad Company was the last owner and operator of an electric trolley line that ran from Watkins Glen to Horseheads, New York. Service ended in 1923 and it had served the communities of Watkins Glen, Montour Falls, Millport, Pine Valley and Horseheads, covering 17.5 miles.
The route followed by this trolley started in Watkins Glen on Franklin Street in the north end of the Village near the tip of Seneca Lake. It proceeded thence along Franklin Street, through the Village and in the roadbed of Rt. 14 to Montour Falls. On arrival in Montour Falls, the trolley followed along the center line of Genesee Street, turning left onto Main Street and turning right (south) onto Catherine Street until it became Rt. 14 and continued in and along Rt. 14 arriving at Millport.
The former car barn at Millport is now renovated and privately owned. Even here, there are no signs of tracks, rails, or roadbed, and at no point yet described are any signs visible. From Millport south the trolley ran along and beside the Penn Central tracks where they now lie and what appears to be the roadbed is visible near Pine City. However, it is heavily overgrown and only visible at certain scattered points. As it nears Horseheads, the roadbed is more easily discernible and less overgrown. Still, in view of the fact that the bed lies directly beside another track, it would be difficult, if not impossible, to use the bed for recreational purposes. As it entered the Village of Horseheads, the trolley ran along the center of streets and, hence, the rails, ties, etc. are not visible at any point.
WATKINS GLEN - MONTOUR FALLS a. Length: 3.5± miles. b. Width: 15± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed not visible, has been paved over by streets and Rt. 14. d. Structures: No visible structures, tracks, ties, etc. e. Indication of ownership: All right of way lying in public domain. f. Nature of terrain: Flat cleared land. g. General land use: Abutting land used for residential, commercial and agricultural purposes. h. Recreational possibilities: Because of presence of roads, recreational possibilities are none. i. Existing transportation facilities: Roadbed located in right of way of Rt. 14.
MONTOUR FALLS - MILLPORT
a. Length: 6.5± miles. b. Width: 15± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed not readily visible at any point since it lies in the center line and shoulders of Rt. 14. d. Structures: Former car barn on western side of the roadbed, now privately owned. All other structures removed. e. Indication of ownership: Roadbed lies in public domain. f. Nature of terrain: Terrain is slightly rolling valley bottom land. g. General land use: Abutting land used for residential, commercial and agricultural purposes. h. Recreational possibilities: Since it lies in the actual right of way of Rt. 14, the recreational possibilities are nil. i. Existing transportation facilities: Located parallel to and 25± ft. easterly of center line of Rt. 14.
MILLPORT - HORSEHEADS
a. Length: 7.25± miles. b. Width: 15± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed is visible at random points - washed out in some places, heavily overgrown, and in the right of way of Rt. 14 in some places. d. Structures: All ties, tracks, bridges and other structures have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: In a number of places the roadbed has been incorporated into abutting residential lots. f. Nature of terrain: Terrain is wet, swampy and generally flat. g. General land use: Abutting land used for commercial, agricultural, and residential purposes. h. Recreational possibilities: Due to roadbed's incorporation in residential lots and the right of way of Rt. 14, its location beside an operating railroad track and sketchy obliteration, the recreational possibilities are nil. i. Existing transportation facilities: Located along side Pennsylvania Railroad tracks and lies in and along Rt. 14.
A. Approximate length 7 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 30'.
C. General Condition The Penn Yan and Lake Shore Railway Company formerly operated an electric trolley line from the Village of Penn Yan to Branchport, New York. Its course ran from a point at the corner of Hamilton Place and East Elm Street in the Village of Penn Yan, thence westerly along the centerline of East Elm Street to the Village limits; thence southerly in and along Route 54-A and West Lake Road. At no point is the roadbed distinguishable because of time and re-use of the property for extensions of seasonal residential lots and/or driveways. It follows along the western shore line of Keuka Lake, varying 30' to 100±' from the water line until it reaches Keuka Park. Here, it goes through Keuka College Campus and turns, heading southwesterly to the Village of Branchport. Along this segment (Keuka Park to Branchport), the bed is still indistinguishable until a point near the intersection of Route 54-A with Esperanza Road outside the Village of Branchport. Here, the bed appears to be located along the bottom of slope on the south side of Route 54-A.
At any rate, the road bed along the entire length of the route would be unsuitable, if not impossible, for any re-use whatsoever. This is because of obliteration by time, private ownership and re-use.
The electric trolley line went into receivership in or before 1933 and was sold to H. Allen Wagener in 1933,
L. 137, P. 611; L. 138, P. 50. a. Length: 7± miles, Penn Yan-Keuka Park-Branchport. b. Width: 30± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed has been regraded in most places while entirety has had cinders removed and been reseeded to grass. d. Structures: Depot has been sold and converted to summer home. Ties, tracks and all other facilities removed. e. Indication of ownership: Entirety privately owned as evidenced by use and condition. f. Nature of terrain: Relatively flat terrain along Keuka Lake. g. General land use: Seasonal (Summer) residences. h. Recreational possibilities: None. i. Existing transportation facilities: Route 54-A runs along and in this trolley bed.
A. Approximate length 14 miles.
B. Approximate width 20' - 30'.
C. General Condition In 1970 the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company discontinued operation on its 14 mile line from Rushville to Naples, New York in Yates County. The specific route followed a course from Rushville in a southwesterly direction through Middlesex and along the eastern bank of the West River to Naples. The roadbed is generally above abutting land grade (2' - 5') except at road crossings where it is at grade. It is only slightly overgrown with grass and lined by trees on two sides for almost its entire length. The only bridge structure is a wooden trestle approximately 30' long, which spans a small stream approximately one mile south of Rushville.
There are several "crossing" signs in place located as follows:
1. William Street Crossing (Middlesex) 1 - 12' x 8" x 8" stand with 2 - l" x 6" x 4' crosspieces
2. Pierce Hill Road Crossing 1 - 10' x 8" x 8" stand with 2 - 1" x 6" x 4' crosspieces
3. Gilbert Street Crossing (Rushville) 1 - 10' x 8" x 8" stand with 2 - 1" x 6" x 4' crosspieces 4. Gilbert Street Crossing (Rushville) 1 - 12' x 8" x 8" stand with 2 - l" x 6" x 4' crosspieces
At Rushville is a depot used for what appears to be a warm weather office and for minor storage. At Middlesex is a larger depot which appears to be completely abandoned as it is empty and has some broken windows. Otherwise, there are no structures.
The only sell-off found in the Yates County Clerk's Office was in July 1967 from the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company to the People of the State of New York,
L. 219, P. 474. This concerned a strip of ROW from the center line of the tracks to the West River Bank, a parcel approximately 500' long and 70' wide. Otherwise, no sales by Lehigh have been recorded.
RUSHVILLE - MIDDLESEX
a. Length: 5± miles; termini @ Rushville and Middlesex. b. Width: 20' - 30'. c. Condition: Since it was only recently abandoned, roadbed is in good condition and intact for entire length. Only slightly overgrown with grass. d. Structures: Tracks have been removed in entirety, though ties are still intact. All other structures (signs, depots, trestle) are in place. e. Indication of ownership: No indicia of private ownership. f. Nature of terrain: Relatively flat swampy land, some wooded and along the base of some foothills near Middlesex. g. General land use: Abutting land uses are agricultural (pasture), recreational, residential and industrial (Rushville). h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking, bicycling, snowmobiling, horseback riding, etc. i. Existing transportation facilities: Roadbed runs along the east and west sides of S. H. 245, crossing it at two points.
MIDDLESEX - COUNTY LINE (NEAR NAPLES, NEW YORK)
a. Length: 9± miles; termini @ Middlesex and Naples, New York. b. Width: 20' - 30'. c. Condition: Since it was only recently abandoned, roadbed is in good condition and intact for entire length. Only slightly overgrown with grass. d. Structures: Tracks have been removed and ties have been pushed to either side of the roadbed, Round metal sign still in place on Cayward Cross Road. No other structures remain. e. Indication of ownership: None. f. Nature of terrain: From Middlesex the terrain is rough and mountainous. As it progresses toward Naples, it becomes flatter and the soil is wet and swampy in many places. g. General land use: The abutting lands are used for woods, agriculture, and residential lots. There is very little, if any, commercial land use in the area. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking, bicycling, snowmobiling, horseback riding, etc. i. Existing transportation facilities: Roadbed runs parallel to and along the western side of S. H. 245, ranging 30' to 150±' therefrom.
A. Approximate length 7 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 20 ft.
C. General Condition The Elmira State Line Railroad Company and Erie Railroad Company formerly operated what was known as the Tioga Branch of the Erie Railroad Company. It was mainly a coal route serving Webb Mills, Seeley Creek, Southport and Elmira. This section was abandoned around 1945 and the right of way has since either been sold, washed into Seeley Creek or reverted back to the lands from which it came. This branch ran from Blossburg, Pennsylvania along Seeley Creek until it tied into an Erie main line just east of Southport, New York.
The specific route followed a southwesterly course beginning at a point known as the State Line Junction and thence proceeding in the same direction along the eastern side of Seeley Creek to Webb Mills. Most of this section has been washed out by the creek except for a 500± ft. strip perpendicular to and on the eastern side of old S.H. 28, where it crosses S.H. 328, on its eastern terminus. The 500± ft. section is easily discernible as it is raised 5 - 7' above the existing land grade. Here, at Webb Mills, the former depot has been converted to a privately owned restaurant. The approximate length of this section is 3.3 miles.
At Webb Mills, the railroad crossed Seeley Creek to its western bank, though no bridge structures are visible. At present, S.H. 328 obliterates the roadbed, as its centerline lies over the actual track bed. This is the case all the way to the Pennsylvania border. The approximate length of this section is 3.0 miles.
The only deed turned up in the Elmira Court House search was to George and Ida Carpenter, L. 362, P. 104. This was a 1000±' section near Webb Mills. Since no transactions were found, it is assumed that abandoned railroad land reverted back to properties from which it first came.
STATE LINE JUNCTION TO WEBB MILLS
a. Length: 3.3± miles. terminal at Webb Mills. b. Width: 20± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed is washed out by Seeley Creek until Webb Mills where it is elevated 5 - 7' above surrounding land grade and is visible approximately 500' in length. d. Structures: No ties, rails, bridges or other structures are visible. Depot at Webb Mills is used as privately owned restaurant. e. Indication of ownership: Ownership reverted to adjoining owners circa 1947. All railroad fences removed and land returned to use of adjoining properties. f. Nature of terrain. Terrain mostly flat land along base of foothills. g. General land use: Abutting land used for highway, rural residences, agriculture (pastures), and tree growing. h. Recreational possibilities: In view of washouts, reclamation, private ownership and highway, the recreational possibilities are nil. i. Existing transportation facilities: Roadbed runs along southeastern side of S.H. 328.
WEBB MILLS TO PENNSYLVANIA BORDER
a. Length: 3.0± miles. b. Width: 20± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed lies under and along S.H. 328, and hence, is not visible. d. Structures: No ties, rails, bridges, or other structures are visible. e. Indication of ownership: No indications of private ownership are visible because S.H. 328 covers entire roadbed. (FARC 62-l90, Southport, Pt. 2, S.H. 28) f. Nature of terrain: Terrain mostly flat and along base of foothills. g. General land use: Abutting land used for residences and low grade commercial. h. Recreational possibilities: In view of washouts, reclamation, private ownership and highway, the recreational possibilities are nil. i. Existing transportation facilities: Roadbed runs in alignment of S.H. 328.
A. Approximate length 32 miles.
B. Approximate width 33 ft.
C. General Condition The Elmira, Corning and Waverly Railroad Company ran an electric trolley line that ran from Corning to Waverly and from Elmira to Horseheads Village. Its last operation was in 1929 and it was sold to the Erie Land and Improvement Corporation in 1930, and recorded in Liber 259, Page 133. This land holding company then resold most of this land to the abutting owners and removed all trolley structures and signal facilities.
The following is a description of the route as it ran from Corning through Elmira to Horseheads Village: SOUTH CORNING THRU BIG FLATS a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 33± ft. (estimate) c. Condition: Seems to have been obliterated between these termini. d. Structures: No existing structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Ownership indicia appears to be private. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat and level. g. General land use: Land use of abutting properties in general is rural farm and residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities are questionable since this land seems to be incorporated into adjacent land usage, and the use for other than present use would probably have an adverse effect to adjacent private properties. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the southerly side of State Rt. 17E.
BIG FLATS TO THE CITY OF ELMIRA LINE
a. Length: 8 miles. b. Width: 33± ft. (estimate). c. Condition: Roadbed is obliterated for a length of approximately 2.6 miles south of Big Flats, but roadbed is evident where it crosses Rt. 17. One bridge structure is evident at this point. Then for a 1,000 ft. distance, it seems to run along a creek and then becomes obliterated again for a distance of 2± miles, At this point it is evident that the line crosses Rt. l7E where Old Arch Bridge can be seen above the highway. For 3± miles from this point to nearly the Elmira City limits, this line is again evident with the roadbed used to service residences as an access road. There is at least one other arch bridge structure in usable condition along this last stretch of the railway line. d. Structures: There is no evidence of any railroad tracks or ties along this stretch of railway. e. Indication of ownership: Ownership indicia appears to be private. f. Nature of terrain: The nature of terrain runs from level out of Big Flats to high and hilly toward Elmira. g. General land use: Principal land use of abutting properties is general rural farm and residential with some occasional small commercial. h. Recreational possibilities: Spots could be suitable to hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Located in vicinity of Rt. l7E.
ELMIRA THRU ELMIRA HEIGHTS
Inside Elmira the Electric Railroad line went from West Water Street branching off and running north along Main Street with side branches about as far as Eldridge Park.
Then at the crossing on Main Street and West 2nd Street this line moved to Lake Street, going northerly out of the Elmira City limits. This line is believed to have run thru the center of streets in the City of Elmira. These streets are all still in existence as public thoroughfares. a. Length: 3± miles. b. Width: Limited to center of streets. c. Condition: Roadbed is city streets. Railway is no longer evident. d. Structures: No existing railway structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Ownership indicia are the City of Elmira and Village of Elmira Heights. f. Nature of terrain: Terrain is generally level. g. General land use: Land use of abutting properties is commercial, industrial and residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Not likely since the line appears to have run in presently existing streets. i. Existing transportation facilities: Located within existing street beds.
ELMIRA HEIGHTS THRU HORSEHEADS VILLAGE
This electric line is said to have followed Lake Street along the easterly side of the street pavement all the way into Horseheads where it ran thru the center of Main Street to the outskirts of Horseheads Village. a. Length: 2 miles. b. Width: Within street right of way. c. Condition: Roadbed appears to have run along the edge of Lake Street pavement until it entered the center of Horseheads Village where it ran along the center of the street thru the village. d. Structures: No existing railway structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Ownership indices are the Village of Elmira Heights and the Village of Horseheads. f. Nature of terrain: Terrain is level. g. General land use: Land use of abutting properties is commercial, industrial and residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities are not likely since the line appears to have run in presently existing street limits. i. Existing transportation facilities: Located within existing street beds.
WAVERLY - ELMIRA CITY SECTION
The Waverly - Elmira section began at a point at the corner of Broad and Elmira Streets in Waverly and proceeded west along the northern side of the current Erie Railroad alignment to Elmira. The bed is visible at most points along this route and is cleared of tracks and ties throughout. It lies directly adjacent to the Erie tracks and varies from 25' to 45' in width. The area through which it runs is mostly rural farmland, but becomes more populated near the villages. The roadbed itself is 5±' above the grade of existing Erie-Lackawanna tracks and is fairly straight in alignment. It follows along the base of several foothills and the Chemung River. The roadbed is in fair condition in most places, being overgrown with grass and brush. One item that should be noted is that the bridges or trestles across road underpasses and streams have been taken out and removed; only the concrete abutments remain. a. Length: 19.5± miles. b. Width: 33±' c. Condition: Roadbed is generally in good condition though somewhat overgrown with brush and grass. At road crossings, the trestles have been removed. d. Structures: Ties, tracks, signals, bridges and all other facilities have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Entirety bought by Erie Land & Improvement Corp, in 1930, recorded in Liber 259, Page 133. The Erie Land & Improvement Corp. in turn sold many segments back to current adjoining land owners. f. Nature of terrain: Terrain is generally hillside from Waverly to the Village of Chemung. Thereafter it is somewhat flat farm land. g. General land use: Abutting land is either unused hillside or agricultural. There is also some residential and commercial, though very little. h. Recreational possibilities: Could possibly be used for hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: This roadbed runs along and adjacent to the existing Erie-Lackawanna Railroad tracks from Waverly to Elmira.
A. Approximate length 39 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 66 ft.
C. General Condition This branch of the Lehigh Valley Railroad began at the westerly line of Ithaca Street in the Town of Horseheads, generally following State Rt. 223 to the south through Breeseport and crossing this State Route in Erwin, thence moving away from State Rt. 223 and moving through the southerly most portion of Schuyler County; then just southerly of State Rt. 224 this line moved into Van Etten Village. Indications are that this branch of the Lehigh Valley Railroad ceased to operate sometime in the mid-thirties. On June 28, 1938, the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company conveyed this stretch of right of way to the Abalan Corp., 143 Liberty Street, New York City, New York. The deed was recorded on June 30, 1938 in Liber 300, Page 234 in the Chemung County Clerk's office. On speaking with the Chemung County Attorney, Mr. Personious, information was given that this stretch of former railroad right of way in Chemung County had been taken over by the County of Chemung for non-payment of taxes. Mr. Personious informed us that the County had conveyed portions of this right of way by tax deed. He also stated that the Abalan Corporation had been conveying portions of this right of way. He further indicated that the County is not sure that it has conveyed proper tax title since it appears that portions of this right of way have not been property described in the town tax assessor's records. It therefore appears that it is questionable as to who really does own the above noted conveyed parcels. It is understood that because of this situation, the County is no longer conveying tax titles. However, the Abalan Corporation apparently is still selling parcels to anyone who will buy.
This abandoned line has a total length of 18.99 miles and terminates in the Village of Van Etten at a line drawn northerly and southerly at right angles to said center line of the Elmira-Cortland Branch at a point distant 925' westerly measured along said center line and center line of Waverly Street in the Village of Van Etten together with all improvements and structures as mentioned in the above noted deed. No right of way width is indicated in the above noted conveyance to Abalan Corporation, however, the County Attorney believes the general right of way width to be 66+ ft. In Tioga County this abandoned railway line was conveyed from the Lehigh Valley Railroad as grantor to the Abalan Corporation. This conveyance was made on December 16, 1937, as recorded in Liber 217, Page 594 of Deeds in the Tioga County Clerk's office. This conveyance describes a stretch of the Elmira to Cortland branch of the railroad being 22 miles long and beginning at the center line of South Main Street in the Village of Spencer easterly and northerly through the Village of Spencer, Town of Spencer and Town of Candor in Tioga County and also through the Towns of Caroline, Dryden and Ithaca in Tompkins County, terminating at the center line of Mitchell Street in the Town of Ithaca. This investigation ends at the Tioga County Line, Mr. Snyder, Chairman of the Board of Assessors for the Town of Spencer does not have the Abalan Corporation as a listed owner of this stretch of railroad land and, in fact, he could not account for this railroad land in his assessment rolls and believes it to be incorporated into private ownership.
The following describes the segments of this railway.
WEST LINE OF ITHACA STREET, TOWN OF HORSEHEADS TO BREESEPORT a. Length: 6± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: The first 4± miles of this roadbed have been obliterated seeming to pass through industrial and dense new residential in the first l to 2 miles, The development then thins out to roadside residential and farm. Beyond the first 4± miles the railroad bed becomes evident following the northerly bank of Newton Creek and passing along the rear of several residential and farm properties. The roadbed in this area is either taken care of as residential lawn or is overgrown in fallow fields for a distance of one± mile where it again becomes obliterated into Breeseport. d. Structures: Railroad structure location could not be determined. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat and rolling. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties in general is industrial, residential and farm. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities of the route are questionable due to the question of parcel ownership. Lands away from developed area could be used for hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the southerly side of State Rt. 223.
BREESEPORT TO ERIN
a. Length: 3± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: Roadbed seems obliterated for the first mile then becomes evident again to the south of Rt. 223. In this area a bridge structure appears to have been removed since a drainage area crosses the roadbed. From here the roadbed is evident for short broken distances into Erin. d. Structures: At least one bridge has been removed from the roadbed and no other signs of structures were evident. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally level to rolling. g. General land use: Generally passes through farm land terrain. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities of route could be hiking. i. Existing transportation facilities: Runs generally adjacent to State Rt. 223.
ERIN TO SWARTWOOD
a. Length: 6± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: At Erin roadbed follows Laurel town road limits for less than l/4 mile then, as this town road increases in elevation, the road follows a creek along a valley for most of the distance into Swartwood. Where the valley and creek meander, the railroad bed apparently crossed the creek back and forth in its meanders. The roadbed varies, in places it is evident and in other places it appears to have been removed. The roadbed along this stretch is mostly in a wild overgrown area which is some distance from any road or highway and very hard to follow. It can be said that access off any roadway is very poor because of the distance that the railroad bed strays from any road or highway. d. Structures: In this stretch of railroad area, it is said by residents that there were many small structures crossing the creek along with a large trestle bridge. It is said that all structures have been since removed. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally wild and in a valley following along a creek. g. General land use: Generally passes through wild brushlands until it becomes evident again in Swartwood. h. Recreational possibilities: Could be hiking. However, route is broken up and along some wild terrain. It is understood some sections are used for snowmobiling. i. Existing transportation facilities: Runs generally la considerable distance from any road or highway.
SWARTWOOD TO VAN ETTEN
a. Length: 3± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: From Swartwood this rail line follows State Rt. 224 to the right being somewhat overgrown in some areas and in other areas it appears that the roadbed has been removed and that the land is being used by adjacent owners. It appears that there are no remaining structures where this railroad line crosses Wynkoop Creek in its meanders. d. Structures: No structures are evident. This line is out by Wynkoop Creek in various places. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally level to rolling. g. General land use: Roadbed generally passes through farm land areas and in some locations has been removed and incorporated into farm land use. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking or snowmobiling. i. Existing transportation facilities: Runs generally to the right some distance from State Rt. 224 moving in the direction of Van Etten.
VAN ETTEN TO SPENCER
a. Length: 3± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: This stretch of roadbed is generally obliterated and appears to have been absorbed into adjacent land use which is generally farming. d. Structures: No structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat to rolling. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is generally agricultural. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities of the route are questionable due to the question of parcel ownership. Lands could be used for hiking if they have not been conveyed into individual ownerships. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the southerly side of Rt. 96.
SPENCER TO CANDOR
a. Length: 9± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: This stretch of roadbed is generally obliterated and appears to have been absorbed into adjacent land use which is generally farming. d. Structures: No structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat to rolling. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is generally agricultural. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities of the route are questionable due to the question of parcel ownership, Lands could be used for hiking if they have not been conveyed into individual ownership. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the southerly side of Rt. 96 until it approaches Canodr, then seems to cross over and run along the northerly side of Rt. 96 into Candor.
CANDOR TO TIOGA COUNTY LINE
a. Length: 9± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: This stretch of roadbed is obliterated in spots but is evident in other locations, Where the roadbed is evident, its condition seems to be generally good. d. Structures: No structures are evident. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia is not known. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat to rolling. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is residential and agricultural. Mostly agricultural or fallow lands. h. Recreational possibilities: Recreational possibilities of the route are hiking or snowmobiling should ownership not be individually sold off. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the westerly side of Rt. 96b.
RECORDED TRANSFER
In Schuyler County the following deed is recorded: Lehigh Valley Railway Company, a corporation in the State of New York and Lehigh Valley Railway Company, a corporation in the State of Pennsylvania
TO
Abalan Corporation, dated June 28, 1938 and recorded July 21, 1938, in the records of the Schuyler County Clerk's office, being a portion of the 18.99 miles of railway line described as running from the westerly line of Ithaca Street in the Town of Horseheads through the Village of Van Etten in the County of Chemung.
A. Approximate length 15 miles.
B. Approximate width of right of way 33' - 66'.
C. General Condition This branch of the railroad began in the Village of Owego in Tioga County extending through the Village of Owego, Town of Owego, Town of Tioga and Town of Candor ending at the southerly line of the Village of Candor where the line, when operating, connected on to the Ithaca Branch of the Lehigh Valley Railroad which is also abandoned (ref. No. 14). This branch of the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad was conveyed to the New York State Electric & Gas Corporation (excluding the portion in the Village of Candor which was conveyed to the Village of Candor). Other exceptions are noted on attachments to this report. It would appear that this line ceased operating sometime in the middle to late thirties. Its right of way width is generally 66 ft. This abandoned part of the railroad started at George Street in the northerly part of the Village of Owego where its right of way would appear to be 33± ft., since the Lehigh Valley Railroad has its Cortland Branch which runs adjacent to the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad track-until the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad track branches off to Catatonk where the right of way would appear to be 66 ft. to the Village of Candor. Total length is about 16 miles.
Ownership of this abandoned line is indicated by conveyances from:
l. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad Company to New York State Electric & Gas Company. Conveyance made on June 21, 1960, as indicated in Liber 297, Page 156, Book of Deeds as recorded in the Tioga County Clerk's office. Exception is conveyance from Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad Company to Arthur Hollenbeck & Son as indicated in Liber 278, Page 301, Book of Deeds. 2. Erie-Lackawanna Railway Company to the Village of Candor. Conveyance made in March of 1961 as indicated in Liber 302, Page 254, Book of Deeds as recorded in the Tioga County Clerk's office. Exceptions in conveyances from: a. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad Company to C. P. Ward & Edgar Van Scoy dated September 23, 1948, in Liber 246, Page 289. b. Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad Company to Ward & Van Scoy, Inc., dated June 16, 1958 in Liber 277, Page 442. c. Erie-Lackawanna-Railway Company to Owego Co-op GLF Service, Inc., dated March 1961 in Liber 302, Page 363.
OWEGO TO CATATONK
a. Length: 4 miles. b. Width: 33' for l± mile and 66' for 3± miles. c. Condition: A good part of this road is still intact with portions obliterated in farm and residential areas. d. Structures: No structures are evident in the general investigation which has been made. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia would seem to be the New York State Electric & Gas Corporation. f. Nature of terrain: Generally low and flat. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is residential in Owego and Catatonk and generally agricultural and scattered residential between these points. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking and snowmobiling. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the westerly side of Rt. 96.
CATATONK TO THE VILLAGE OF CANDOR
a. Length: 10± miles. b. Width: 66± ft. c. Condition: Except for a few spots where the bed has been removed generally for agricultural purposes, most of the bed remains but is somewhat wildly overgrown with brush. A boy interviewed, claimed to ride parts of the bed on his minibike. d. Structures: Same boy mentioned in Item c claims that 3 or 4 structures on this portion of railroad bed have been removed. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia would seem to be same as mentioned in Owego to Catatonk portion. f. Nature of terrain: Generally low and flat. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is generally rural agricultural and scattered residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Hiking, snowmobiling and minibike use. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally seems to run along the westerly side of Rt. 96.
THROUGH THE VILLAGE OF CANDOR
a. Length: l± mile. b. Width: 66 ft.
C. Condition: Roadbed is still in place at southerly end of Village of Candor. It appears to be used as a street (Del Ray Avenue) the rest of the length in Candor all the way to Main Street where it is assumed that it connected on to the former Lehigh Valley Railroad line. d. Structures: No evidence of any structures in existence. e. Indication of ownership: Exact ownership indicia would seem to be the Village of Candor. f. Nature of terrain: Generally flat. g. General land use: Land use of adjoining properties is generally residential. h. Recreational possibilities: Since the village seems to be using most of the railroad bed in the village limits as a street, recreational possibilities would seem to be nil. i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally runs through the Village of Candor, a good portion being known as Del Ray Avenue.
A. Approximate length 10 miles. B: Approximate width of right of way none in evidence.
C. General Condition This was a proposed railroad from Savona thru Bradford to Wayne. It was graded from Savona almost to Bradford. Construction took place two different times around the year 1900. Mr. Harry Joint an octogenarian, proprietor of the local hardware store in Savona, and lifelong resident of Savona, stated track was laid in the Village of Savona around 1902. He further stated that the railroad was never completed nor any tracks laid outside the village. d. Structures: None e. Indication of ownership: A Search was made in the County Clerk's records in Bath for certificates of corporation, railroad name filings, bankruptcies, dissolution of business, or land transfer and none were found. f. Nature of terrain: Mostly flat land in valley between rolling hills. g. General land use: Farm, residential and recreational h. Recreational possibilities: None i. Existing transportation facilities: Generally parallel to S.H. 226.
A. Length: 4.3± miles (No evidence of trolley line Hornell to Arkport.)
B. Width: Generally 2 rods.
C. General Condition The first cars operated in the City of Hornell on August 4, 1892. They extended operation to Canisteo that same year, and for all purposes the line was completed. Operation was suspended in 1926. The physical assets of the defunct railroad were sold in bankruptcy proceedings to Raymond E. Page for $17,600. The following is a public record of the various companies making up Hornell Traction: Chartered Hornell Electric Railroad Company December 15, 1891 Hornell & Canisteo Electric Railway Company December 28, 1891 Canisteo Valley Electric Railway Company May 2, 1892 Hornell Street Railroad Company March, 1894 Hornell Traction Company 1909 All evidence was removed by reconstruction of State Highway 5221; N.Y.S. touring Route 36, mostly on new location. d. Structures: "Car barns" now occupied by Strobel's Welding Service, 75 Adsit Street, Hornell, New York. e. Indication of ownership: Private f. Nature of terrain: Flat land to side hill. g. General Land Use: Industrial h. Recreational possibilities: None i. Existing transportation facilities: S.H. 5221, N.Y.S. touring Route 36.
A. Approximate length 16 miles
B. Approximate width of right of way none in evidence
C. General Condition These (2) railroads, along with the Bradford, Bordell and Kinzua Railroad were part of what was known as the "Bradford, Bordell and Kinzua Narrow Gage System". This system was built to provide service to the oil fields in northern Pennsylvania and the Allegany region of southern New York State.
HISTORIC BACKGROUND
The Bradford, Eldred, and Cuba Railroad routing was from Eldred, Pa. to Cuba, N.Y. through Ceres and Little Genesee, N.Y. It had branches from Little Genesee through Bolivar, Allentown, Petrolia, to Wellsville. The Wellsville terminus was near the former Wellsville municipal airport site. There also was a short branch from Bolivar to Richburg. A careful physical search of the area of right of way disclosed no evidence of any remaining existence of railroad. This railroad was completed September 21, 1881; in January of 1893 it was sold at a foreclosure sale; and by May of 1893 all salvage was removed.
(l) BRADFORD-ELDRED-CUBA
a. Length: 18 miles b. Width: Unknown c. Condition: No evidence of roadbed. d. Structures: None e. Indication of Ownership: Allegany County Clerk's Office, Index of Conveyances by Corporations, years 1893-1921, pages 85 and 122. f. Nature of terrain: Valley land g. General land use: Farm land and recreational land h. Recreational possibilities: None i. Existing transportation facilities: State touring Routes 305 and 275.
HISTORIC BACKGROUND
The Tonawanda Valley and Cuba railroad was also completed about 1881. It ran from Cuba to Arcade, and was abandoned about 1893. The only evidence remaining of this railroad is an old station outside of Rushford, New York, that is now used by a local business for storage. There is no evidence of railroad right of way.
(2) TONAWANDA VALLEY & CUBA
a. Length: 36 miles b. Width: Unknown c. Condition: No evidence of roadbed. d. Structures: Station at Rushford. e. Indication of Ownership: Allegany County Clerk's Office, Index of Conveyances by Corporations, years 1893-1921, pages 85 and 122. f. Nature of terrain: Valley 1and, some side hill. g. General land use: Farm land and recreational land. h. Recreational possibilities: None i. Existing transportation facilities: State touring Routes 243 and 98; Allegany County Routes 7, 7A and 7B.
A. Approximate length 10.3 miles
B. Approximate width 66 feet
C. General Conditions: The road bed is in good condition except for places where the Genesee River has washed away most of it. One section is about one mile south of Wellsville and the other is about five miles south of Wellsville. It is a cinder and dirt covered right of way that can easily be followed. The track has all been taken up to the Pennsylvania State Line. The ties have either been removed or pushed off the right of way the entire length.
D. Structures: The railroad depot at Wellsville is still standing. There is a railroad bridge (wood) that crosses the Genesee River for the connection with the Erie Lackawanna Railroad that is still there but in poor condition. There are three wooden and one steel bridges between Wellsville and the Pennsylvania State Line. These all seem to be in good condition.
E. Indication of Ownership: The railroad still owns most all of the right of way. The County of Allegany is trying to get Federal funds with Potter County in Pennsylvania to purchase the right of way. The railroad sold a short portion of the right of way from the Genesee River bridge to the Erie Lackawanna Interchange to Rodney Collins, a lumber dealer to be used as a spur for his lumber business. The sale was recorded in the Allegany County Clerk's Office on October 4, 1973, Liber 625 page 265.
F. Nature of Terrain: Level to rolling.
G. General Land Use: Farming and recreation.
H. Recreational Possibilities: Hiking, biking, horseback riding, snowmobiling and cross-country skiing.
I. Existing Transportation Facilities: State Route 19 and River Road (a town road) parallel the right of way.